Le Wild Explorer
Cocktail Recipes Cocktails Around The World North America Puerto Rico Travel

Piña Colada Recipe | Cocktails to Drink in Puerto Rico

The beloved Piña Colada is a rum-based drink that originated from San Juan, Puerto Rico. It is said to be created by Ramon “Monchito” Marrero in 1954 at the Beachcombers Bar at the Caribe Hilton. It’s been an internationally known drink ever since. If you like Piña Coladas (and getting lost in the rain… haha) check out my Piña Colada recipe below.

pina colada with pineapple

This post contains affiliate links. If you click my link, I make a small percentage (at no extra cost to you). This helps me keep the travel blog running.

pina colada ingredients

What You’ll Need

Light Rum
Dark Rum
Pineapple Juice (made from fresh pineapple is preferred but if buying in the can get 100% juice “not from concentrate”)
Coconut Cream
Coconut Milk
Angostura Bitters
Large Knife for cutting pineapple
Cutting Board
Juicer (if juicing pineapple at home)
Parasol Picks (Cocktail Umbrellas)
Maraschino Cherries

Rum Recommendations

There are tons of different rum selections but if you’re using this Piña Colada recipe for a party then I suggest being economical. My recommendation is to go with Bacardi Light Rum and Plantation Original Dark. These two rums won’t break the bank and you’ll still have great-tasting cocktails.

Piña Colada Recipe

2 ounces – Light Rum
1 ounce – Dark Rum
3.5 ounces – Pineapple Juice
1.5 ounces – Coconut Cream
1 ounce – Coconut Milk
2 dashes – Angostura Bitters
Pineapple slice with cherry or pineapple leaf garnish (optional)
If you’re feeling extra add a parasol cocktail pick!

pineapple pina colada in hurricane glass

How to Make a Piña Colada

Juicing Your Pineapple

To make your Piña Colada you’ll start by juicing your pineapple. A large pineapple will get a bit under a liter. Medium-sized pineapples will get you about a half liter. You can juice the pineapple with a juicer (easiest way) or blend then strain with a fine strainer. You’ll have to move around the pulp to get the most juice out of it.

Add Ingredients To Your Blender

Add all your ingredients inside your blender. If you’re making more than one multiply the recipe. Once you added all the ingredients add half the amount in ice. It’s helpful if your blender has measurements on the side (like below).

blended pina colada blender

Pour your Piña Colada into your cocktail glass. I recommend a 16-ounce hurricane glass. And garnish to your liking!

pina colada cocktail and pineapple

Enjoy your Piña Colada! And if you want more “Cocktails Around the World” check out my other recipes.

If you tried this Piña Colada recipe leave a comment below and share a pic on Instagram with the hashtag #lewilddrinks.

Pin it for later!